Pizza Fair Haven NY

Fresh & Hot pizza and subs!

Bayside Grocery makes pizza and boy is it good! Made fresh and cooked within minutes, you can take this to go extra fast if you call ahead! We also make subs and have a full deli selection available too for any side dishes you may want. Stop by and say hello and pick up a pizza! Sold by the slice too!

Check the Menu Here!

non-ethanol gas &  propane

Bayside Grocery Non-Ethanol Gas is available year-round and around the clock. Offering top-grade fuel for all of your auto, ATV, snowmobile and boating needs! We also offer propane!

Bayside Grocery - Fair Haven, NY
Bayside Grocery - Fair Haven, NY

Full Service Store, Deli & More!

Bayside has all your needs in one-stop! We have everything available from food to drinks, gas and propane, ice and beer, camping & hardware supplies and everything in between! Stop by for that last minute item that you’re missing and say hi to our friendly staff.

Bayside Grocery - Fair Haven, NY